iPad top side
iPad left side
  • 05:36

  • frog life

    Froglife

  • Incentivated @ Thorpe Park video

    Day out at Thorpe Park

  • Waitrose

    Waitrose

  • Google Get Mobile

    Google Get Mobile

  • MnS

    Wallace & Gromit

  • thmbnl

    COI

  • terminate

    Virgin 1

  • MnS Orange Juice 2D barcodes

    M & S Food to go

  • Recycle for London

    Recycle for London

  • Cabwise

    Mayor of London

  • Back to Home icon

    Back

Loading...
iPad bottom side
iPad right side

Things are said here

minus

Incentivated

  • Blogs
  • video
  • Tweet
  • Linked In
Mobile | Desktop
10 Years
  • Home
  • Our platform
    • Introduction
    • App frameworks
    • Auto callback
    • Basket recovery
    • CRM & loyalty
    • Device detection
    • Mcommerce
    • Mobile coupons
    • Mobile vouchers
    • Location marketing
    • QR and barcodes
    • Reporting
    • Shortcodes
    • Text messaging
    • Text to landline
    • Transcoding
  • Our services
    • Apps - native
    • Apps - hybrid
    • Design & UX
    • CRM
    • Managed services
    • Media
    • Mobile email
    • Mobile internet
    • Mobile SEO
    • Mobile strategy
    • Testing
  • Our work
    • Case studies
    • Press coverage
    • Awards
    • Product summaries
    • White papers
    • Video case studies
    • Sector guides
  • Contact us
  • IRIS
  • Other posts

    • All Posts (32)
    • <-- Previous entry
    • Next entry -->
  •  

    Responsive, but not completely mobile optimised

    01 May
    2013

    Tweet
    • Author:   Jason Cross

      ----------------------------
      Blog Image

      ​Kudos to MCC and Lord's for recognising that their visitors/ members will likely be looking at their website on their phones as much as on computers (especially when they are at the ground).


      I received an email from MCC telling me of the launch of their re-vamped website this week, and as part of this re-introduction to the new site they were, quite rightly, showing off that it was "responsive", as you can see from this excerpt from the email

      -----------------------
      2. Responsive (optimised for mobile)

      The new site is responsive, which means that it will recognise the device that you are using and display content accordingly. We are now able to communicate more effectively with Members and the general public on their tablets and mobiles - and this aspect of the project is a huge improvement. The ability to target and engage with mobile users is key as internet usage on mobiles continue to grow.
      -----------------------

      Intrigued by this, I had to go and have a look on my phone. And, yes, Lords.org has been built with a responsive design. And it has some nice features, such as the top menu button which drops down, pushing content down the page; having a prominent search button and being able to log in.

      But I also noticed some issues. I thought at first there was a design error, as when it first loaded I had a large and glaring black space between the top of the content and the menu bar. It took a few minutes, but eventually this loaded as a photo of the ground itself.

      So, I entered the URL into ready.mobi, suspicious that the site, whilst it might be responsive, is not adaptive with server side hosting and delivery of appropriate assets. Low and behold,  the Ready.mobi stats show it up. The home page is well over 1.7MB in size, it scores a "2" (that's not great) for mobile optimisation; page load time of 431 seconds (that's over 7 minutes!!) on a less than optimal mobile network connection (you know, the one we mostly experience) and has 18 technical issues that could be improved upon, according to the analysis engine.

      Because it took so long for the main image to load, I assume it is the same file as used on desktop, just re-sized for my phone screen, rather than my phone loading both the desktop and mobile versions of the image (when I would expect the phone image to be visibly a touch quicker). 

      This is not untypical, and the site is a vast improvement - and it does look lovely and work well. But it is also a very common cautionary tale that illustrates the point that just because your site is "responsive" it doesn't mean it has been "optimised" for mobile. 

      (And there's a further conversation that will need addressing soon: what happens if I view your site on my 40" connected TV? I am guessing all the images will pixelate horribly, because, again, the assets are a fixed size and resolution).

      Categories:
      • |
      • Responsive Web Design
      • |
      • Technical
      • |
      • Mobile internet